Something unusual happened recently in the US markets. Commercial real estate stocks were slammed so hard you’d think we were back in 2008. One major brokerage name suffered one of its worst days ever – rivalling the carnage of Covid and the Global Financial Crisis. Meanwhile, trucking and logistics stocks were hit as if demand had collapsed overnight. But it didn’t.
There was no recession announcement. No credit freeze. No oil shock.
The trigger? AI
Artificial intelligence.
Investors are suddenly gripped by the idea that AI will make offices obsolete, automate freight brokers out of existence, crush logistics margins, and hollow out white-collar services from software to wealth management.
Welcome to what traders are calling the AI scare trade.
The question is…
Is this the beginning of a structural collapse, or the setup for a massive overreaction?
When fear moves faster than reality
Markets don’t wait for proof. They price in narratives. And right now, the narrative is simple.
AI makes workers more efficient…
Fewer workers are needed…
Less office space is required…
Margins get squeezed…
Profits fall…
It sounds simple and logical. But real economies are rarely that tidy.
AI is a productivity tool. And productivity gains don’t automatically translate into destroyed industries. Often, they expand them.
Think about spreadsheets. They didn’t eliminate finance departments. They made them bigger.
Email didn’t kill offices. It accelerated business.
E-commerce didn’t destroy logistics. It supercharged it.
The leap from “AI improves efficiency” to “entire sectors collapse” is enormous. And markets may have sprinted across that gap.
The office isn’t just a desk
The argument against commercial real estate goes like this: If AI reduces headcount, companies need less space.
But offices aren’t just containers for employees. They’re hubs for collaboration, client meetings, training, culture, and deal-making.
Hybrid work didn’t eliminate offices. It reshaped them. And even in a more automated world, companies still need:
• Physical presence for high-value collaboration
• Central hubs for client-facing teams
• Space for labs, studios, creative work
• Infrastructure for data centres and AI operations
Ironically, AI itself requires enormous physical infrastructure – from server farms to specialised facilities. That demand flows straight back into real estate.
Trucking isn’t an algorithm
Logistics stocks were hammered on fears that AI freight tools will eliminate inefficiencies and compress margins.
But logistics is not a pure software problem.
It involves drivers, weather, regulations, fuel costs, warehouses, port bottlenecks and human decision-making
AI can optimise routes. It can forecast demand. It can reduce empty miles.
That’s helpful.
But helpful doesn’t equal catastrophic.
When logistics became more efficient in the past, volumes grew. Faster systems attracted more business. Better routing didn’t shrink the industry – it expanded throughput.
If AI reduces friction, it may increase total freight activity rather than shrink it.
Productivity doesn’t always equal profit collapse
Investors assume that if costs fall, profits must fall too.
But that’s not how markets usually work.
When industries become more productive, three things tend to happen:
• Company’s lower prices to gain share.
• Demand increases because services become cheaper.
• Strong players widen their moat through scale.
The leaders often benefit most.
AI may hurt weak operators. It may compress fees for undifferentiated players. But it can also strengthen companies that adopt it fastest.
The stock market is currently acting as if every company is the weak link
AI will change how work gets done. That part is undeniable.
But change does not automatically equal destruction.
When stocks drop as hard as they did – rivalling crisis-era declines – it tells you something important.
Emotion is in control. Fear spreads faster than earnings revisions.
Right now, AI is being treated not as a tool but as a wrecking ball. Entire sectors are being repriced based on what might happen, not what has happened.
When markets panic before fundamentals shift, that’s often where opportunity hides.
Not a subscriber to Money Morning?
You can get free daily recommendations like these with Money Morning eletter. Just sign up here.
